top 12 albums of 2009. couldn’t do just 10.

We’ve had such an outstanding year for music, I couldn’t get down to 10. Albums in the top 5 could have been other years’ best record. Without further ado …

12. M. Ward, Hold Time — If anyone’s gonna make money from their music playing in Bud Light ads, may as well be someone as distinctly skilled as Ward. His musicianship, offbeat arrangements and voice sounding like an old soft sweater probably deserve a campaign with a better beer. Best song: The beerselling yet ingratiating shuffle of “Never Had Nobody Like You.”

11. Dex Romweber Duo, Ruins of Berlin — He doesn’t have the voice of when he led Flat Duo Jets, but Dex’s rockabilly is way cooler than anything on the radio. He’s learn to adjust what he does over the years, but stays true to his musical influences. Best song: “Picture of You,” a jaunty yet plaintive rockabilly gem.

10. Madeline, White Flag — A fine example of songwriting in the Southern gothic tradition. Consider her Neko Case’s deeper voiced long-lost cousin from the sticks. Best song: “This Train,” a folk throwback train song.

9. Green Day, 21st Century Breakdown — I’ll admit it. The first time I heard “Longview,” I never dreamed the band would be this good and for so long. But this testament to 21st century living, the agony and the ecstasy, is a worthy follow-up to American Idiot. Best song: The most upbeat tune, “Last of the American Girls,” where they let their California roots infuse their post-punk ethos.

8. Tegan and Sara, Sainthood — Tegan and Sara albums usually take a while to grow on me, but I’m still not digging this as much as many previous efforts. Plenty of good head-bobbing riffs and make-you-think lyrics though. Best song: “On Directing,” a vintage example of their catchy licks and clever songwriting.

7. Good Old War, Good Old War — Better harmonies than even Crosby, Stills and Nash. There, I said it. This group is a revelation, a throwback to a time when honest-to-goodness vocals were more important than studio tricks. Best song: “Tell Me,” one of the prettiest songs you’ll expect to ever hear.

6. David Gray, Draw the Line — Gray felt his music was getting stale (I’d agree), so he ditched his band and started from scratch. He brings a new energy and outlook, but fortunately his usual vocal prowess remains. Best song: The odd coupling of Gray with Annie Lennox on “Full Steam Ahead,” a lot of singing skills on one track.

5. Butterfly Boucher, Scary Fragile — Between this effort and Flutterby, the British songstress has recorded two of the most overlooked albums of the decade. With lyrical, musical and vocal skills, she’s got it all, and maybe someday the world will notice. Best song: With its deep-breath introduction, ultracatchy melody line and stop-go-stop setup, “I Found Out” isn’t just the best song on this album, I’d give it the nod for Song of the Year.

4. Tragically Hip, We Are the Same — The latest from my favorite band features more great stories marvelously told by Gordon Downie surrounded by solid musicianship. There’s a deeper feeling to this release than much of their catalog, and Gordie’s vocals seem to get better with age. Best song: “Coffee Girl,” which would be a huge hit in some alternative universe.

3. The Damnwells, One Last Century — Track after track of catchy rock tunes wonderfully rendered. And did I mention the band released it as a free download? This mostly unheralded band seems incapable of recording a bad tune. Best song: Kind of a toss-up between gorgeous ballad “Dandelion” and rocker “55 Pictures.”

2. Matthew Good, Vancouver — The newest and best of a very impressive catalogue combined the cinematic sweep of Avalanche with some of the intimacy of Hospital Music. The songs are larger than life with the stories running the gamut from war (as always) to small-town frustration to his concerns about what’s happening to his hometown of Vancouver. Best song: “Us Becomes Impossible,” grammar issues notwithstanding, is a perfect example of the powerful build Good masters.

1. Avett Brothers, I And Love And You — Masterfully written, performed and produced (hat tip to Rick Rubin). The Avetts have always had the ability, but sometimes sloppiness kept this from becoming evident. Here, it’s all focused on their ability. Easily the album of the year. Heck, I have it as the #2 song of the decade. Best song: The title track, which will take residence in your head so long you’ll have to charge it rent.

There you are. Did I miss anything?



Filed under words

5 responses to “top 12 albums of 2009. couldn’t do just 10.

  1. I’ve got my list down to 40, and I see three from your top 12 that are high up on my own list (M.Ward, Green Day and the Avett Brothers). Thanks to you and the best-of-decade project, I’m starting to get into Tegan and Sara, whom I’ve overlooked throughout the decade. I can’t quite get into the David Gray album and I have yet to check out Good Old War.

  2. I do like the Avett Brothers, but haven’t checked out the album beyond the title track just yet. It has received much praise, but I am suspicious it’s the typical gratuitous fanfare that automatically comes with a Rick Rubin production.
    I also love Rubin, though, so I shall assess and follow up on that one.
    You know how I feel about T & S. While Madeline won’t make my top 10, she is a worthy entry.
    Well done!

  3. Thanks for the great list, Tim. I am admittedly not much of an album buyer (with the exception of holiday music) but you have highlighted some of my favorites. Green Day’s East Jesus Nowhere has helped me survive this very crazy semester (the tune, not so much the lyrics). Thanks to you and Andrew for improving my musical repertoire.

  4. insidetimshead

    ANDREW: If you like harmony and Americana stylings, I highly represent Good Old War. I had the additional honor of seeing them live = amazing. Oh, and thanks oodles for your Top 100 project (again) because it helped drive this list.

    SHANE: Really, I can see why not everyone (which is to say you) would like T&S. Not exactly like sugar. #12 to 5 were all pretty close, really, and while I don’t think “White Flag” is Madeline’s best, it has some nice tunes. The Avett Brothers are well worth the praise … I like each and every song.

    DEBRA: It’s funny how many of these tunes I bought because of Twitter recommendations. If Andrew, Ron and Georgy all say something is good, I’ll pretty much buy it.

  5. Pingback: top 2009 lesson: twitter is other people. « InsideTimsHead

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s